Forming One’s Professional Identity

by Alex Craig, PharmD, PGY1 Pharmacy Practice Resident, University of Mississippi Medical Center

Making the transition from pharmacy student to practicing pharmacist is challenging.¹ New pharmacists are tasked with actively applying learned materials in their everyday practice as well as problem-solving when areas of practice are often more gray than black and white. During this transition, a pharmacist’s professional identity plays a crucial role. Professional identity has been defined as “a representation of self, achieved in stages over time during which the characteristics, values, and norms” of the profession are “internalized, resulting in an individual thinking, acting, and feeling” like a health professional.² Those with strong professional identities tend to be confident, driven, and adaptive when faced with uncertainty.³ I believe professional identity can and must be actively developed through thoughtfully designed student experiences.

Over the last two decades, there has been an explicit effort to teach “professionalism” in health professions education. In recent years this has evolved and helping students form their “professional identity” during their journey to become healthcare professionals has become the educational objective.⁴ In 2014, the American College of Clinical Pharmacy formed a task force on how to help foster professional identity formation. The task force made recommendations for best practices, created a framework for educational methods to support the formation of professional identity within interprofessional contexts, and generated recommendations to support faculty in helping students develop their professional identities.⁵

Facilitating professional identity formation requires consideration of many factors: What kind of pharmacist (generalist, specialist, practice setting) does the student pharmacist want to become? What are the hallmark characteristics society needs in a pharmacist now and into the foreseeable future? What processes are in place to support and promote identity formation?¹ Forming a professional identity is a dynamic process with many influences.  It is influenced not only by the student’s personal identity, but also factors such as clinical/non-clinical experiences, role models/mentors, formal instruction, self-assessment, reflection, and socialization. Among these, role models/mentors and experiences appear to have the biggest impact. In professional identity formation, a positive mentor/mentee relationship is facilitated by constructive feedback. Feedback serves as a reinforcement of learning and it assists in the confirmation of the learner’s self-perception.⁴ Preceptors and mentors can aid in identity development by sharing personal experiences and encouraging the student to shift into an independent mindset. For example, when encountering a situation where the best decision is unclear, the preceptor should encourage the student to express their thoughts and suggest potential solutions. Encouraging students to combine foundational knowledge with recent literature and applying that to a patient case or practice management scenario can facilitate this independent thinking.  Indeed, students should be encouraged to be responsible for making choices and this should align with who they want to become as a healthcare professional. Exposure to increasing complex scenarios can also help prepare students for their future practice. There also needs to be opportunities for students to share and reflect on their experiences and what was gained or learned. This may be facilitated through debriefing sessions that are student-led.⁴

A 2019 scoping review investigated pharmacy student professional identity formation.¹ The paper pointed out important aspects to be considered when developing curricula to foster professional identity formation. First, it's important to examine how pharmacy students see themselves. Pharmacy students often lack an understanding of their professional selves and are unable to articulate what it means to be a pharmacist. Pharmacy students tended to focus on traditional pharmacist roles (dispensing and counseling) and this understanding was reinforced by experiential learning and part-time work experiences. Pharmacy students also found it challenging when engaging with patients when they were met with disinterest or anger. Experiences gained within the pharmacy curriculum often led to unresolved identity dissonance because students’ practice experiences did not align with the idealist view taught in the classroom about the pharmacist role.¹ This includes ambiguity about the definition of “clinical” pharmacy. For example, the definition of “clinical” often vary by practice setting, and students perceive big differences in the role and responsibilities of pharmacists in community, ambulatory care, and hospital settings. Some educators suggest that role-play activities can help encourage students to merge the gap between the “ideal” professional role and their lived experiences. Students should be given opportunities to discuss their experiences with a trust role model and re-enact how they responded to the experience.  This enables students to envision their professional identity but also critically examine their personal identity.⁶

To facilitate professional identity formation, faculty will likely need to be educated about the construct. It is important that faculty understand that students must participate in developing their own professional identities and maintaining a welcoming environment for open dialog is critical.  The curriculum should address known factors that affect identity formation and there should be a mechanism to assess student progress. Some schools engage students in the development of professional identity by using reflective strategies.³ This strategy can consist of some foundational instruction about professional identity formation and periodically asking student pharmacists to reflect on their stage of development. These reflections can help gauge the student’s understanding, track their progress, and identify gaps. A tiered approach is needed and activities should be appropriate for the learner’s stage of development.

I challenge you to think about your own transition into practice and your understanding of your role. What experiences did you have that fostered the development of your professional identity? What experiences or role models do you wish you could have had during your training?

The aim is not to homogenize all personal identities into a standard; rather, the student maintains his or her ‘self-identity’ while building a professional identity through exposure to diverse experiences while upholding the key virtues of a … professional including competence, kindness, honesty, and integrity.⁷

References:

1. Noble C, McKauge L, Clavarino A. Pharmacy student professional identity formation: a scoping review. Integr Pharm Res Pract. 2019; 8: 15-34.
2. Cruess R, Cruess S, Boudreau J, et al. Reframing medical education to support professional identity formation. Acad Med. 2014;89(11):1446–1451.
3. Scanlon L. “Becoming” a professional. Dordrecht: Springer; 2011. 
4. Cruess S, Cruess R, Steinhert Y. Supporting the development of a professional identity: General principles. Medical Teacher. 2019; 41(6): 641-649.
5. American Association of Colleges of Pharmacy. Taskforce on professional identity formation – final report. 
6. Monrouxe LV, Rees CE, Endacott R, et al. “Even now it makes me angry”: health care students’ professionalism dilemma narratives. Med Educ. 2014; 48(5): 502–517.
7. Forouzadeh M, Kiani M, Bazmi S. Professionalism and its role in the formation of medical professional identity. Med J Islam Repub Iran. 2018; 32: 130.